top of page

Chanukkah: Remembering Who We Are

6 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

As we turn the calendar, December in the North County often means the start of winter, late sunrises, early sunsets, and snow. With the dwindling amount of light, it’s easy to withdraw into our homes as we begin the hibernation process. One way in which we combat the cold, dark desire to isolate is by celebrating the ever-timely Festival of Lights; Chanukkah. Temple Beth Israel will celebrate our Chanukkah party on Friday, December 11th at 5:30pm. We will have a place to light our Chanukiahs (Chanukkah menorahs), play dreidel games, sing lots of great holiday songs, and of course eat plenty of latkes, sufganiot, and gelt.


I often view Chanukkah as a uniquely Jewish event. The eight-day Jewish festival commemorates the Maccabees who reclaimed and rededicated the Jerusalem Temple in 164 BCE, along with the miracle of a one-day oil supply which burnt for eight days. However, the Chanukkah story also highlights the dangers of assimilation. For the Jews who lived through the original Chanukkah story, many had to choose between assimilating into all things Greek, including idolatry through polytheism and maintaining a traditional Jewish life, focused around Temple sacrifices. The deciding factor was when Greek influenced-Jews stopped circumcising their baby boys. What ensued was a twenty-five-year civil war between Jews who had adopted Greek customs and Jews who followed customs as assigned in the Torah. What began as a way to integrate the best attributes of Greece and the Greek culture, ended up almost overwhelming Israel and the Jewish people. Chanukkah is one of the few Jewish holidays not mentioned in the Torah, yet based on an undisputable historical event; the oil lasting 8 days is a matter or faith, but the war was real, and the Jews won. 


The dangers of assimilation are still omnipresent. As Jews living in the United States, we have worked tirelessly to assimilate and integrate within American culture and society. For the most part, we have been rewarded handsomely for our efforts to be the best version of Americans. However, I am beginning to realize and appreciate the limits of assimilation and integration. A hundred years ago we saw first generation Jews drop their European accents as English slowly replaced Yiddish in the major urban ghettos. Fifty years ago, the Jewish experience had become so successful and so accepted, that Jews began to marry non-Jews. Thanks in large part to the suburbs, Jews and gentiles began to live side-by-side; schools, hospitals, and country clubs began to welcome Jews. While nobody argues the benefits to the social acceptance that accompanied a general retreat of antisemitism across most areas of this country, the assimilation and integration of the American Jew came at a cost.


In our effort to blend-in, feel more accepted, and normalize Jewish customs, we married non-Jews, stopped attending Hebrew School, and what it has meant is that frankly folks who identify as Jewish don’t know as much about Judaism, and they don’t feel as closely connected to Judaism and Israel as in previous generations. It’s unpopular to write and it angers some, but in an effort to be well liked and accepted in the larger realm of American society, we lost our Jewish ways. This is not an attack against interfaith or mixed-Jewish households. There is no greater rabbinic proponent of Jews falling in love, marrying/cohabitating with anyone their heart desires. We always champion the beauty of diversity; conversion and interfaith households have made Judaism and the Jewish family better in so many ways. However, when one’s partner isn’t Jewish, it leaves a lot of Yiddishkeit left to be taught and warmly embraced. As a result of all these beautiful interfaith families, formal Jewish education took a hit, and some Jews no longer identify with fundamental Jewish values. 


Somewhere along the line, thanks in large part to liberal progressive political values, diversity diluted Judaism into something indistinguishable. Liberal progressive values have become conflated with progressive Jewish values.  Zionism has always been a Jewish value; the belief that Jews are entitled to live in Israel is not a device created for the purposes of modern, political Zionism. Aliyah and the Jewish settlement of Israel are what Abraham and Moshe dedicated their entire lives towards, in order that all Jews for all times may have a land to call home. This is not a modern invention and acting as such is a disservice and distortion of basic Jewish belief. We need to educate Jews and non-Jews alike that while Israel is not the only place Jews can inhabit, it is the home-land of the Jewish people, and it’s not debatable. There is no easy or comfortable way to say it, but Anti-Zionism is incompatible with Judaism and the sooner folks begin to understand this fact, perhaps the sooner folks can begin to understand and appreciate modern Judaism’s relationship with the land of Israel. 


When we light the Chanukkiah, let us take a moment to think about how we wish to balance our Jewish identities with the reality that we live in a very non-Jewish world. Do we think the answer is to hide our Stars of David and to throw Israel under the bus for having the audacity to exist, or do we double-down and tell people unapologetically that Zionism is a part of ancient Jewish belief? How can we continue to gather around the Chanukkiah year after year to light candles, if we don’t know what we are truly celebrating? 


Chag Chanukkah Samaech,



Comments


Contact Us

1 Bowman Street

Plattsburgh, NY 12901

USA

Main Office: 518-563-3343

Keep In Touch

Stay up to date with our latest community news, events and opportunities.

Give Online

Honor or remember someone with a donation

Copyright © 2026 Congregation Temple Beth Israel

bottom of page